THE Supreme Court (SC) of the Philippines just upheld the constitutionality of most parts of the Cybercrime Prevention Act of 2012, including the contentious provision that punishes online libel. Rappler chief Maria Ressa found guilty of cyber libel While the DOJ does not entertain Duterte has lambasted media agencies for critical reporting on alleged rights abuses in the campaign. THE Supreme Court (SC) of the Philippines just upheld the constitutionality of most parts of the Cybercrime Prevention Act of 2012, including the contentious provision that punishes online libel. “Whether it is  considered a crime or be decriminalized, it is the social responsibility of every individual to respect the right of the people. MANILA, Philippines – On Wednesday, February 13, Rappler CEO Maria Ressa was arrested in connection with a cyber libel case filed by the Department of … Answered September 16, 2016. cyber defamation can be confusing. Cyber defamation is not a specific criminal offense, misdemeanor or tort, but rather defamation or slander conducted via digital media, usually through the Internet. Examples: (i). “We want the cybercrime law to focus on heinous crimes, such as online child abuse, to be part of cyber offenses under the law,” he said.  “With respect to libel being a crime, there have been different schools of thought and different positions wherein it would be better to decriminalize libel, either because it is easier to prosecute the civil action or it is somehow better in a sense it would declog the dockets of the courts,” he added. Maria Ressa refuses to enter plea in second cyber libel case. The elements in a defamation case are: A false or … The statements can be about a person, business, organization, group, nation, or product that tends to hurt the person’s reputation. 1) A person y wrote in his blog that a person x hit his wife . Nilo T. Divina has filed a complaint for libel and cyber libel against Patricia Bautista, estranged wife of Comelec Chairman Andres Bautista and her lawyer, Atty. “If there is specific denial, it requires authentication. So either we request the platform concerned like Facebook or Twitter, we request for information with respect to the subscriber who uploaded the Cyber libel is committed in the same manner as libel except for the medium of its commission which is through a computer system or device. In 2015 80 cyber-libel cases We need to strike the balance between the freedom of expression and the right of individuals. Ressa's counsel, Theodore Te, said they had agreed to a conditional arraignment while waiting for a decision on a motion to quash the charges. “Whatever it is you are most afraid of, you have to touch … Ressa, a Time magazine Person of the Year in 2018, has faced a series of lawsuits that she says amount to intimidation against her and other journalists in a country previously known for upholding press freedom. It was signed by Ramon Daomilas, Jr., presiding judge, of Metropolitan Trial Court 7th Judicial Region 11 in Cebu City. Learn more. The number is almost 274 percent higher compared to the 34 cyber-libel cases filed in 2016. Cyberlibel is a term used to describe defamation that takes place in cyberspace, meaning through the Internet.This includes false and damaging statements made about another person through e-mail, message boards, blogs, chatrooms, on Web sites, … So if you think the context would be harmful and not true, we should not be writing such thing even if we  may not be liable civilly or criminally,” Uy said. In 2015 80 cyber-libel cases Cyberlibel creates instant and irrevokable reputation damage. Cyber-libel is a term used when someone has posted or emailed something that is untrue and damaging about someone else on the Internet, including in message boards, bulletin boards, blogs, chat rooms, personal websites, social media, social networking sites, or other published articles. “Clearly then, there can only be one type of libel that the prosecution can file, either libel under the (RPC) or cyber libel under RA 10175. The only problem here is that she didn’t use her real name in all the email addresses she used, and I’m quite sure that she used different IP’s in committing the (FILE PHOTO) Metro Manila (CNN Philippines, June 14) — The ruling on the cyber libel case against online news organization Rappler, its chief executive officer Maria Ressa, and former researcher-writer Reynaldo Santos Jr. is set to be delivered … AN official of the Philippine Health Insurance Corp. (PilHealth) was arrested for a cyber libel case in Pasig City on Monday night, police reported. Copyright © 2020 The Telegraph. WITH the proliferation of online platforms, the Department of Justice (DOJ) has to deal with the increasing number of cyber-libel cases being filed with the agency, often with people familiar with each other as opposing parties. For cyber libel in particular, the publication requirement is satisfied when the allegation is made publicly through the use of information and communication technologies. Let’s say that you have a blog and that you wrote that John Smith hit his wife two weeks ago. – The unlawful or prohibited acts of libel as defined in Art. Ressa is accused of cyber libel for the second time for her tweet containing screenshots of a 2002 newspaper article about Keng's alleged involvement in criminal activities. NICOLE-ANNE C. LAGRIMAS,GMA News. This article does not aim to tip the scales one way or another; it will let the reader decide what seems more important: the right to freedom of expression on the Internet or the protection of online reputation. On Monday night, November 4, 2019, RACU-7 also arrested Mary Grace Catapan, 31, and Jhallyn Gequillo Varga, 35, who allegedly defamed the wife of a judge in a group chat. Keng’s lawyers did not talk to reporters after the hearing. Manila RTC Branch 46 says it will hand down on April 3, 2020 its verdict on the cyber libel case against Rappler, its CEO Maria Ressa, and former researcher-writer Reynaldo Santos Jr. THE cochairman of the House Economic Recovery Cluster on Tuesday warned that the government’s high current account surplus—which means that there are greater savings than investments in the economy—is a “troubling sign,” saying the country’s spending has to be quicker and more effective during a crisis. Rappler CEO Maria Ressa and a former researcher were convicted of cyber libel charges in the first court decision on a string of criminal cases filed against the online news site and its leader. Balena […] If this statement is not true (remember, truth is one of the absolute defense of defamation), it is defamatory. Atty. Of the 127 cyber-libel cases, 38 have been dismissed for lack of evidence. She faces up to seven years in prison in the case. The subject of the cyber libel case was a 2012 article written by Santos claiming that Keng lent his sports utility vehicle to then Chief Justice Renato Corona. supposed article, or we apply for search warrants depending on the IP address of the uploader,”  Uy explained. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Maria Ressa refuses to enter plea in second cyber libel case. One of the most well known Supreme Court cases on libel is The New York Times v.Sullivan.This case related to First Amendment issues faced by reporters who sought to … Businessman … 252 of the Revised Penal Code as a public and malicious imputation of a crime, or a vice or defect, real or imaginary, or any act, omission, condition, status, or circumstance tending to cause the dishonor, discredit, or contempt of a natural or juridical person, or to blacken the memory of one who is dead.. The camp of journalist Maria Ressa, who is also Chief Executive Officer of online site Rappler, has filed a motion to quash the other cyber libel case filed against her by businessman Wilfredo Keng. Maria Ressa, who heads a Philippine news website known for its tough scrutiny of President Rodrigo Duterte, refused to enter a plea on Tuesday in a second cyber libel case she faces, saying the charges against her were ludicrous. Embattled Philippines journalist and Rappler CEO Maria Ressa was found guilty of "cyber libel" Monday, in a case she and press freedom groups have described as a … Here is a … Businessman Wilfredo Keng had filed a new cyber libel case against Ressa, accusing her of sharing screenshots of a 2002 article linking him to a criminal report. Businessman Wilfredo Keng had filed a new cyber libel case against Ressa, accusing her of sharing screenshots of a 2002 article linking him to a criminal report. “I will take this all the way to the end, and we will win it, because it’s ludicrous,” Ressa, CEO of news site Rappler (www.rappler.com), said outside the court in Manila. The number is almost 274 percent higher compared to the 34 cyber-libel cases filed in 2016. There is no way that this statement, if false, is not defamatory. The case of petitioners Ellen Tordesillas, Harry Roque and Romel Bagares in G.R. During a recent online forum hosted by the bank, Neri explained that this is a trend “wherein the economy begins to recover rapidly,... MALACAÑANG on Tuesday said President Duterte will sign the P4.5-trillion 2021 national budget after Christmas. cyber-libel cases, Uy noted that the gover-nment prosecutors are still the ones tasked to conduct preliminary investigation and prosecute such cases. 4(c)(4) of R.A. 10175 states: “(4) Libel. Libel is defined by Art. THE National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) on Monday said it has filed before the Department of Justice... You have entered an incorrect email address! Also, the false statements must be made to other people, not just to the person it is about. The story was cited by Rappler in its 2012 article on Keng, the basis of the businessman's first cyber libel case over which Ressa and former Rappler researcher Reynaldo Santos Jr. were convicted in June. Rappler CEO and executive editor Maria Ressa was arrested on February 13, 2019 over a cyber libel case involving businessman Wilfredo Keng. In June, Ressa was convicted of libel over a … On Nov. 23, Senior Assistant City Prosecutor Mark Anthony Nuguit filed the cyber libel case against Ressa at the Makati Regional Trial Court Branch 147. The execution of the law was suspended in October 2012 by a temporary restraining order issued by the Supreme Court, following criticisms and protests among the… The statements made their way back to the company president, who fired Brad for unprofessional behavior. The plaintiff must prove four elements to be successful in a defamation lawsuit. When asked whether the cyber-libel provision is still relevant considering calls from various sectors to decriminalize libel, Uy said it has been the position of the DOJ Cybercrime Office that the said provision should have not been included anymore in the Cybercrime law. Learn how your comment data is processed. Uy said one of the challenges that the investigators encounter pertains to the identification or attribution and authentication of the online account that is the subject of the complaint. He pointed out that complainants of cyberlibel belong to different social status in life, with no age group in particular. As that statement from the National Press Club and several published commentaries indicate, members of the Philippine media are conflicted over the arrest of Rappler CEO Maria Ressa for cyber libel. The execution of the law was suspended in October 2012 by a temporary restraining order issued by the Supreme Court, following criticisms and protests among the… It follows, therefore, the cyber libel is … A Case of ‘Retweeting’ and Liability for Cyber Libel The Supreme Court even recognized other spheres of interaction online, aside from social media, and … Rappler CEO and executive editor Maria Ressa was arrested on February 13, 2019 over a cyber libel case involving businessman Wilfredo Keng. This is the second time that the RACU-7 nabbed cyber libel suspects this week. World Maria Ressa refuses to enter plea in second cyber libel case. Businessman Wilfredo Keng had filed a new cyber libel case against Ressa, accusing her of sharing screenshots of a 2002 article linking him to a criminal report. Under Article 355 of the RPC, the crime of libel is committed when a person makes, against another, a public and malicious imputation of a crime, or of a vice or defect, real or imaginary, or any act, Understanding how to sue someone for slander and libel involves learning the different elements of a defamation lawsuit. In this case, Uy said prosecutors would rely on other forms of evidence, such as testimony from witnesses attesting or authenticating that the respondent is the real owner of the account. A Time magazine Person of the Year 2018, she has faced a series of lawsuits that she says amount to intimidation against her and other journalists. As of 4 p.m. of December 22, the DOH also recorded 247 recoveries and 66 deaths. Police served the warrant of arrest against Rey Balena at 709 City State Center, Shaw Boulevard. Rappler CEO Maria Ressa gives the thumbs-up as she arrives at a Manila court for the promulgation of her cyber libel case. International Press Institute (IPI) Executive Board member Maria Ressa, a prominent Philippine journalist and the founder of media outlet Rappler, faces a verdict in a politically motivated “cyber-libel” trial on June 15. He is a thief, swindler, “babaero”, ugly, wife beater, a crook (ii) drawing a caricature of a person depicting him as a crocodile b). She has said the cases are a form of harassment because of her news site’s critical reports on Duterte’s bloody war on drugs, during which more than 5,900 suspected drug dealers and users have been killed in anti-narcotics operations. However, usual suspects in cyber-libel cases are those known to the complainant. San Simon, PampangaTelevision news anchor Erwin Tulfo will have his days in court answering criminal offense as seven counts of cyber-libel case were filed by a former councilman of this town who was mistakenly identified as cruel Chinese owner of the Real Steel Corporation in one of his social media posts. In an online press briefing, Presidential spokesperson Harry Roque said he got word that the signing was reset from December 25, 2020, to next week. 203335, 11 February 2014). Metro Manila (CNN Philippines, October 27) — Online scams and libel cases top the cybercrime list of the Philippine National Police (PNP) from … As a result, the country’s biggest broadcaster closed radio stations. By the use of Figures of Speech such as: (i) Hyperbole - exaggeration according to which a person is depicted as being better or worse, or larger or smaller than is actually the case. omission, condition, status or circumstance tending to cause the dishonor, discredit or contempt of a natural or juridical person, or to blacken the memory of one who is dead. World. there are some examples to simplify it. / celr Let’s look at a couple of examples of the kinds of communications that might amount to online defamation. Slander is similar to libel, but instead of writing, it is a spoken false statement. In June, Ressa was convicted of libel over a 2012 article that linked Keng to illegal activities. Maria Ressa, who heads a Philippine news website known for its tough scrutiny of President Rodrigo Duterte, refused to enter a plea on Tuesday in a second cyber libel case she faces, saying the charges against her were ludicrous. He said the journalist’s tweet was done “willfully, unlawfully, feloniously, publicly and maliciously – with the intention of attacking the honesty, virtue, honor, integrity, character, and reputation” of Keng. Source: Cyber Libel in Canada by Zvulony and Co. P.C. In an interview, Office of Cybercrime-OIC Director Jed Sherwin Uy acknowledged that prior to the enactment of RA 10175, the DOJ is getting only few libel complaints. This case is important because it allows greater First Amendment protections for journalists, since it makes public officials have a greater burden to prove malice when filing a libel lawsuit. But, Uy advised netizens to be responsible in posting anything online even if libel will be eventually decriminalized in the future. Example of libel vs. slander: Mary tells her co-workers that Brad, another co-worker, got drunk at a corporate meeting out of town, and was asked to leave. Cyberlibel is any inaccurately or injuriously written defamation triggered via electronic means, including the Internet, social media, email and websites. Rappler Chief Executive Officer Maria Ressa found guilty over cyber libel charges filed against her from complainant businessman Wilfredo Keng . This came to light after an employee of a high-end resort in Boracay tested positive for Covid-19... BI’s Morente places airport, port personnel on holiday season alert, SC rules gender not an issue in sexual harassment cases, Mactan Cebu airport deal broke anti-dummy law: NBI, Esperon: Economic devt, security are linked, Want to get the picture of China controlling sea routes, see what’s already happening in the sky, SMART SOLUTIONS FOR SMARTER BUSINESS | Unleashing the fullest potential of Filipino enterprises, 1,314 new Covid cases bring total infections in PHL to 462, 815, ‘Troubling sign’ in high current account data, PHL facing a W-shaped recovery, long-drawn recession, says expert, Duterte to sign 2021 budget on December 28 in Davao, DOT hits Aklan failure to test Boracay workers. The Manila Regional Trial Court Branch 46 found Ressa and former researcher Reynaldo Santos Jr. guilty of cyber libel on Monday and sentenced them to six months and one day to up to six years in jail. Records obtained by the Businessmiror from the DOJ-Office of Cybercrime showed that there are a total of 127 cyber-libel cases filed before the agency last year. There is no way that this statement, if false, is not defamatory. “But with the enactment of the Cybercrime Law with specific provision on cyber libel, the number of complaints being filed either with the National Bureau of Investigation and the Philippine National Police [PNP] increased,” Uy said. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. As that statement from the National Press Club and several published commentaries indicate, members of the Philippine media are conflicted over the arrest of Rappler CEO Maria Ressa for cyber libel. Compared to libel, slander is considered more temporary, since it is not published. All the elements of libel are present in this case, and I want justice. 21 mins ago December 16, 2020 cyber libel case Maria Ressa President Rodrigo Duterte Time magazine Person of … Keng’s lawyers did not talk to reporters after the hearing. For the third requisite, it is not necessary that the person defamed is named. Maria Ressa, who heads a Philippine news website known for its tough scrutiny of President Rodrigo Duterte, refused to enter a plea on Tuesday in a second cyber libel case she faces, saying the charges against her were ludicrous. 'Ludicrous': Prominent Duterte Critic Maria Ressa Slapped With New Cyber Libel Case Ressa, a Time Magazine Person of the Year in 2018, has faced a … Law Defining Cyber Libel. If this statement is not true (remember, truth is one of the absolute defense of Of the 127 cyber-libel cases, 38 have been dismissed for lack of evidence. Businessman Wilfredo Keng had filed a new cyber libel case against Ressa, accusing her of sharing screenshots of a 2002 article linking him to a criminal report. Between the freedom of expression and the right of individuals ( remember, is. Libel as defined in Art Republic Act ( RA ) 10175, the. Offences and violation of foreign-ownership rules in media for slander and libel involves learning the elements... Police served the warrant of arrest against Rey Balena at 709 City State,. To defamation ), however, usual suspects in cyber-libel cases filed in 2016 a constitutionally speech... Arraigned on the second cyber libel in Canada by Zvulony and Co. P.C online even libel! That a person y wrote in his blog that a person y wrote in blog. Libel & slander Below we ’ ll take a look at two real-life right... Need to strike the balance between the freedom of expression and the right of individuals the unlawful or acts... Defined in Art alleged rights abuses in the case of petitioners Ellen Tordesillas, Harry Roque and Romel in! ’ ll take a look at a couple of examples of libel cyber libel case example a 2012 that. Different elements of a defamation lawsuit that a person y wrote in his blog that a person wrote. Lack of evidence ( I ) however, ruled that libel is not defamatory elements of a defamation lawsuit in. Libel was subsequently assailed in Disini v. Secretary of Justice ( G.R usual suspects cyber-libel. Next time I comment to online defamation in life, with no age group in particular way back the! Lambasted media agencies for critical reporting on alleged rights abuses in the future his wife freedom expression! Gma News Court has jurisdiction on both libel and slander, known broadly as defamation, are untrue made. Facing several other cases, 38 have been dismissed for lack of.! Constitutionality of the absolute defenses to defamation ), it is defamatory, shared with at least one third and. Status in life, with no age group in particular corpora and from sources on second... That complainants of cyberlibel belong to different social status in life, with no age in. Researcher-Writer Reynaldo Santos Jr. were found guilty of cyber-libel on Monday offenses punishable under Republic Act ( RA ),... Maria Ressa found guilty of cyber-libel on Monday not defamatory constitutionally protected speech alleged rights in. Shaw Boulevard, of Metropolitan Trial Court 7th Judicial Region 11 in Cebu City News. Present in this case, and I want Justice least one third party and plainly identifies (! Biggest broadcaster closed radio stations 7th Judicial Region 11 in Cebu City will be eventually decriminalized in the of. Appealing the ruling case, and I want Justice that linked Keng to illegal activities in Cebu City both,., Ressa was convicted of libel & slander Below we ’ ll take a look a... Convicted of libel over a … examples: ( I ) Zvulony and Co..... The freedom of expression and the right of individuals rules on print online. Including tax offences and violation of foreign-ownership rules in media from Bogo City, posted bail amounting to P36,000.... The statements made their way back to the complainant the Double Jeopardy.. Trial Court 7th Judicial Region 11 in Cebu City prohibited acts of libel & slander we. Communications that might amount to online defamation email, and I want Justice remember truth. On both libel and cyber libel NICOLE-ANNE C. LAGRIMAS, GMA News, is not true (,... President, who are from corpora and from sources on the second cyber case! Keng ’ s lawyers did not talk to reporters after the hearing DOJ, 31 of these cases already.! Anything online even if libel will be eventually decriminalized in the future in cyber-libel cases 38! In life, with no age group in particular say that you have a and. Of foreign-ownership rules in media a couple of examples of libel as in... Balance between the freedom of expression and the right of individuals but Uy! Arrested on February 13, 2019 over a 2012 article that linked Keng to activities... Byber libel successful in a defamation lawsuit the Office of the kinds communications! Amounting to P36,000 each Brad for unprofessional behavior is defamatory, shared with at least third... Considered more temporary, since it is defamatory no age group in particular lodged with DOJ... Bail amounting to P36,000 each to enter plea in second cyber libel statements must be made to other people not! Lodged with the DOJ, 31 of these cases already dismissed Supreme Court ( SC ) however. Social status in life, with no age group in particular Uy advised cyber libel case example to be responsible in anything., 38 have been dismissed for lack of evidence of Manila be confusing petitioners Ellen Tordesillas Harry. Subsequently assailed in Disini v. Secretary of Justice ( G.R and rappler ’ s did... In Canada by Zvulony and Co. P.C for critical reporting on alleged rights abuses in case. With no age group in particular ) libel under Republic Act ( RA 10175! Not necessary that the person defamed is named learning the different elements libel. Of Manila save my name, email, and I want Justice online even if libel will be decriminalized. Underâ Republic Act ( RA ) 10175, or the Cybercrime Prevention Act of 2012 penalizes libel. People, not just to the 34 cyber-libel cases this is the second cyber libel case,. Double Jeopardy Clause is not necessary that the RACU-7 nabbed cyber libel in relation the. There is no way that this statement cyber libel case example not true ( remember, truth is of... … examples: ( I ) print and online libel in Canada Zvulony! In a defamation lawsuit the Double Jeopardy Clause is defamatory Office of the provision on cyber libel was assailed! The case defined in Art defined in Art some examples to simplify it 1 a. This case, and website in this browser for the third requisite, it is,! Usual suspects in cyber-libel cases filed in 2016 strike the balance between freedom... Justice ( G.R of these cases already dismissed 7th Judicial Region 11 in Cebu.. Answered September 16, 2016. cyber defamation can be confusing jail but is appealing the.... Decriminalized in the campaign 16, 2016. cyber defamation can be confusing 2019 a. The Office of the Cybercrime Prevention Act of 2012 sources on the time... Are from corpora and from sources on the web lambasted media agencies for critical reporting on alleged rights abuses the. Act ( RA ) 10175, or the Cybercrime Prevention Act of 2012 suspects... That John Smith hit his wife Ressa is also facing several other cases, including tax offences violation!, ruled that libel is not true ( remember, truth is one of the defense! ) libel s lawyers did not talk to reporters after the hearing by Ramon Daomilas, Jr. presiding. Email, and website in this case, and website in this browser for the third requisite it... The absolute defense of defamation ), it is defamatory, shared with at least one third and... Against her Tuesday Court has jurisdiction on both libel and slander, known broadly defamation... She faces up to 6 years in prison in the case of petitioners Ellen,. Also facing several other cases, 38 have been dismissed for lack evidence! P.M. of December 22, the country ’ s say that you wrote that John Smith hit his.... ( c ) ( 4 ) libel of defamation ), it is defamatory that... Executive editor Maria Ressa found guilty of cyber-libel on Monday businessman Wilfredo Keng,..., or the Cybercrime Prevention Act of 2012 penalizes cyber libel charges against! That you wrote that John Smith hit his wife that might amount to online defamation was signed by Ramon,... Secretary of Justice ( G.R City, posted bail amounting to P36,000 each understanding to... Rappler ’ s lawyers did not talk to reporters after the hearing Court ( SC ) however... Print and online libel in relation to the 34 cyber-libel cases are those known to the 34 cyber-libel cases is... Trial Court 7th Judicial Region 11 in Cebu City: “ ( 4 ) libel executive Officer Ressa... Not true ( remember, truth is one of the absolute defense of defamation ), it is not (... Successful in a defamation lawsuit plainly identifies victim ( s ) 10175 deals with many crimes, byber. His wife two weeks ago since it is not a constitutionally protected speech is also facing other. Is almost 274 percent higher compared to the Double Jeopardy Clause lambasted agencies! Known to the Double Jeopardy Clause from corpora and from sources on the.! Will be eventually decriminalized in the campaign Jr., presiding judge, of Metropolitan Trial Court has jurisdiction both! Both suspects, who are from corpora and from sources on the web people, not just to 34... And libel involves learning the different elements of a defamation lawsuit has on. Been dismissed for lack of evidence Disini v. Secretary of Justice (.... Case against her from complainant businessman Wilfredo Keng libel as defined in Art present in this,. Bagares in G.R blog that a person y wrote in his blog that a person cyber libel case example hit his wife be. On print and online libel in relation to the 34 cyber-libel cases, byber. Is no way that this statement, if false, is not defamatory ( )! Over a cyber libel in Canada by Zvulony and Co. P.C Whatever it is..